The bar is OPEN—and tonight, the arguments get serious!

The Thought Brothers are back with another round of BARROOM ARGUMENTS, and this time we have a surprise guest joining the conversation: comedian Nicky Sunshine!

Gary Johnson, Bill Spivey, Carlos Prillman, Stan Harrison and Nicky Sunshine step up to the bar for two ridiculous—but surprisingly difficult—debates where everybody has to make a choice.

A catastrophic failure is about to wipe out four legendary music catalogs. You have enough storage capacity to permanently preserve the complete recorded catalog of only ONE artist for future generations: Aretha Franklin — Whitney Houston — Tina Turner — Dolly Parton.

Everything from the other three disappears. The recordings are gone. Future generations can ONLY read about them and know they existed, but they can NEVER hear their music again.

Whose catalog do you save?

THE LAST SONG — You are on your deathbed surrounded by family and friends. Yes, the end is near. Your immediate family is gathered on one side of the bed, and the Thought Brothers are on the other side. You are still of sound mind. You can hear only one of these women perform one song live at your bedside before you die. Which singer are you choosing to perform live?

Again, your choices: Aretha Franklin. Whitney Houston. Tina Turner. Dolly Parton. You only get ONE.

Who are you choosing—and more importantly, what song are they singing?